The Widow of Brewton

Four husbands. Four sets of insurance policies. Two graves.

Brewton, Alabama, is the kind of Southern town that makes you ease your foot off the gas.

Downtown Brewton, Alabama

Drive through downtown, and someone raises a hand as you pass. You wave back, though you’re fairly certain you’ve never met. A couple of folks stand talking on the sidewalk, neither showing much interest in ending the conversation. Beneath the shade trees, front porches look like sensible places to spend an afternoon.

Nobody seems to be in much of a hurry. Stay a little while, and you begin to wonder why you were.

It’s a pleasant place. Quiet. Quaint. The sort of town where you could imagine knowing your neighbors and being glad you did.

Then you come to the creek.

Murder Creek.

Bridge over Murder Creek near Brewton, Alabama.

You glance at the name, then back at the water.

Hmmm.

That’s a name with a story behind it. For a moment, you consider stopping to ask someone. But there’s another story to hear first—one that takes you back to 1950, when a woman stood trial in Brewton and people had good reason to talk.

Her name was Bessie Lee Cunningham.

The Widow.

Bessie Lee’s first husband lived after she divorced him. So did her second. The third and fourth were not so fortunate.

But in 1934, when she married Leonard Clark, there was no reason to suspect that her marriages would one day become the subject of a murder investigation.

The First Husband

Clark was a farmer living near Atmore, Alabama. He and Bessie remained together for approximately twelve years and had children before their marriage ended.

According to Clark, Bessie left him for another man in 1946. She and her boyfriend, Horace Johnny Huggins, moved to central Florida. He later gave her twenty acres and a home as part of their settlement.

Their relationship ended, but one financial connection remained. Bessie continued carrying life insurance on him. There was nothing inherently criminal about that. Years later, however, investigators would find reason to ask about it.

The Second Husband

On June 1, 1946, Bessie married the man she ran off with – Horace Johnny Huggins, a carpenter and mechanic. All was not rosy, however. Their marriage lasted about seven months.

Huggins later told authorities that Bessie had purchased approximately $10,000 in insurance on his life, using his money to pay the premiums. He also said she continued carrying insurance on Clark.

Eventually, Huggins went to Tennessee looking for work. A week later, he received a letter indicating that Bessie intended to find another man. Their divorce followed. Huggins survived the marriage. He later told investigators that he did not believe Bessie had tried to poison him.

The Third Husband

In March 1947, Bessie married Willie Eugene Cunningham, a carpenter and farmer in the Atmore area. By the spring of 1949, Willie was seriously ill. He suffered stomach distress and vomiting. According to Bessie’s later account, blood appeared in his vomit. She maintained that he had experienced stomach trouble before their marriage.

On May 11, 1949, Willie died at forty-seven. He was buried in Robinsonville Cemetery near Atmore, and Bessie collected life insurance. She later said the money went toward debts. His death might have remained a sad chapter in a family’s history…

Then Bessie married his younger brother.

The Fourth Husband

Arthur Cunningham became Bessie’s fourth husband within months of Willie’s death. Before long, Arthur began suffering headaches, weakness, and stomach trouble. Bessie said he had a history of headaches and fainting spells. Some relatives described a man whose health had declined sharply.

Uh…there was insurance again. According to contemporary newspaper reports, a $5,000 policy naming Bessie as beneficiary was issued just twenty-five days before Arthur died.

His daughter, Olivett Williams, later testified about an unsettling incident during his illness. Arthur had been taking pink medicine, she said, but Bessie offered him a cup containing green liquid. When he questioned the color, Bessie reportedly threw it away. The accounts do not establish that the liquid was tested or contained poison. Arthur died in late August 1950. He was forty-four.

This time, authorities investigated.

What the Bodies Revealed

An examination of Arthur’s body revealed arsenic. Investigators then arranged for Willie’s remains to be exhumed. Arsenic was found in his body, too. Officers also discovered poisonous compounds at the Cunningham farm, including an agricultural pesticide containing arsenic. Bessie maintained that the chemicals had been used on crops.

She denied killing either husband.

At her trial in Brewton, a state toxicologist testified that Arthur’s body contained arsenic in quantities five to ten times greater than necessary to cause death. Willie’s remains contained even more. Prosecutors argued that Bessie had poisoned Arthur for insurance money. Her defense emphasized that no witness had seen her administer arsenic.

On November 2, 1950, the jury found her guilty of first-degree murder in Arthur’s death. Its recommendation of mercy spared her execution. She was sentenced to life imprisonment.

An Unfinished Ending

A 1964 newspaper article reported that Bessie was paroled under Florida supervision, and there is indication that she settled in the Bradenton area. The available accounts leave the date and her subsequent life unclear. They also do not establish whether she was ever tried for Willie’s death.

Her first two husbands survived to tell investigators about their marriages. Her third and fourth lay in the same cemetery. There is no report of poisoned husbands in the Bradenton area, either.

The insurance policies alone had proved no crime. But after two brothers died with arsenic in their bodies, those policies became part of a story that led from an Alabama farmhouse to a murder verdict in Brewton.

Many people have never heard of this story. They don’t know about the Brewton Widow. But now you do.

Michael Earl Simmons


Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 thoughts on “The Widow of Brewton”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading