The Man Who Was Hanged Twice: Pensacola’s Darkest True Story

Pull up a chair and let the evening settle in. Around here, folks love to spend late October trading manufactured ghost stories and haunted house jump-scares. But when darkness drops over the brick walkways and moss-draped live oaks of historic Downtown Pensacola, the honest truth is that the documented past is far more gripping than any piece of folklore.

Take the turn of the century, right here in the heart of town. In the autumn of 1899, a young woman named Victoria Watkins decided she had reached the end of her rope with her lover, Wayman King. When King flatly refused to marry her, Victoria didn’t make hollow threats—she broke off the courtship on the spot and told him in no uncertain terms to get out of Pensacola and never come back.

But King didn’t pack his bags. The very next day, he walked straight back to Victoria’s house, pulled a concealed pistol, and ended her life right where she stood.

What followed was an intense, two-county manhunt across dense pine flatwoods and river bottoms before lawmen finally ran King to ground along the railroad tracks over in Santa Rosa County. Bound in irons, he was hauled back across the bay to Pensacola to stand trial. The verdict was swift, and the sentence was final: death by hanging.

On the day the gallows were readied, the town gathered to watch – as much as they could see – justice take its course. The noose was adjusted, the black hood was drawn, and the trapdoor gave way.

Then, the unthinkable happened. Something went so terribly, violently wrong on that gallows that the incident earned King a chilling title in Pensacola lore: the man who was hanged twice. What transpired in those harrowing minutes after the drop fell is a scene that still leaves folks speechless more than a century later—and to understand how and why it happened, you have to stand where the lawmen stood.

I’m Michael Earl Simmons, a retired police sergeant and former homicide detective with thirty years in law enforcement. I bring that experience into the telling—the small detail that deserves a second look, the decision that changes everything, the question an investigator would know to ask.

And I tell it the way I’d tell you a story on a Southern porch: pull up close, get comfortable, and let me take you back.

The stories are carefully researched, grounded in real events, and told with respect for the people who lived them. Their power comes from the history itself. No ghost needs to step out of the shadows when the truth waiting around the corner is this compelling.

Costumes are welcome. Curiosity is encouraged. Comfortable walking shoes are a good idea – although the walk is only around the square.

Seven True Crimes. One Historic Walk.

This Halloween, trade the theatrical haunts for pure, unvarnished history delivered with the cadence of an authentic Southern storyteller. Some of these places you may have passed a hundred times. After hearing their stories, you may find yourself slowing down the next time you walk by.

This isn’t a cheesy gore-fest or a routine ghost walk. It’s a deep, meticulously researched true-crime journey through the streets where these events actually unfolded—led by a 30-year veteran law enforcement officer and former homicide detective. You aren’t getting dime-store rumors; you’re getting real forensics, crime-scene dynamics, motives, and the hard facts of how justice was pursued in the Old South. As we walk through downtown, stopping at the exact ground where history turned on a dime, you’ll hear seven fascinating cases spanning from 1763 to 1996:

  • The Man Who Was Hanged Twice – The terrifying sequence of events on the gallows that rewrote execution history in Pensacola.
  • The Murder of Pensacola’s Mayor – A brazen daylight assassination that sent shockwaves through early territorial Florida.
  • The Suspicious Death of the West Florida Governor – Untangling an untimely demise surrounded by political intrigue and lingering doubts.
  • The Plaza Ferdinand Prison Break – Desperate convicts, a frantic escape, and their capture right in the city square.
  • The Burglar Who Heard from God – While inside, he met with an unexpected and divine detour.
  • A Mother’s Cold Revenge – What happens when the legal system falls short and family justice takes the reins.
  • The Murder of a Ship’s Captain – A brutal maritime killing on the bay, and the singular, calculated act that finally balanced the scales.

Step Into Pensacola’s Past

Come walk the shaded streets, hear the evidence firsthand, and discover what really happened when the sun went down on Pensacola’s history. Costumes are not necessary but welcome if you’re feeling festive, but the stories you’ll hear are 100% real.

So, join me this Halloween. There’s something I want to show you downtown.

Sweet Tea Murders: Crimes Around the Plaza Walking Tour in Historic Downtown Pensacola
Saturday, October 31, at 4:00 p.m.
Meet at the Bodacious Olive, 407 South Palafox Street
Allow approximately 75 minutes.

Reserve your place and come discover what really happened in Pensacola’s past.


Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading