Cold Blood and Half-Truths: An Investigator Revisits the Davis Murders

A Sweet Tea Murders story

One thing I learned from my days as an investigator is this: Seldom does a suspect “confess” to exactly what occurred. Even in the midst of an admission, the human mind wants to verbalize an incident in the best light of the person telling the story. Stories often change when the suspect realizes it doesn’t fit the narrative. That happened with the murder of Mr. and Mrs. Marius and Nancy Davis.

Everyone knew them as Uncle Bud and Aunt Nancy. They were an elderly couple – in their 90s – content to live out their lives in the middle of the Choctawhatchee National Forest – part of today’s Eglin Air Force Base in the Florida Panhandle, just outside of the community of Wright. Bud, a Confederate Veteran, was a lookout for the U.S. Forestry Service. The Davis’s also owned a bunch of cattle and were said to have $1500 stashed away. That is about $40,000 in 2026.

They were a close family. Even at their age, their son and daughter came around regularly. They were visiting on March 21, 1917, when three men came to the front gate and asked for food and water. In the old South, no one was refused food and water. McDonald’s wasn’t around the corner like it is today, so something was always given.

They learned that the three men, Robert & Will Blackwell and Will Boyd, were from the town of Holt, Florida, about 20 miles north as the crow flies. After they ate, they got up, thanked the couple, and left. Harrison and his sister also left. Harrison, a forest fire fighter, was summoned to a nearby forest fire.

After the son and daughter had left, they heard gunshots coming from the direction of their parents’ house. They ran back and discovered both of them dead from gunshot wounds. And the money? It wasn’t taken. It appeared that the murderers simply panicked and fled after the deed was done.

Okaloosa County was only two years old, and this was a first test for Sheriff B.H. Sutton, who proved himself when he arrested the Blackwell brothers and Boyd within two days. He soon got a confession by Robert, who described how he was the most innocent of the three. Eventually, however, Will Boyd testified against the brothers.

Robert said that the three returned after the son and daughter left and demanded the trunk of $1500 cash that was reported to be there. When the old soldier reached under his mattress for his trusty Winchester rifle, Robert shot him. A total of six shots were fired, killing them both. One newspaper account said that Nancy died with her grandbaby in her arms.

Will, for his cooperation, received life in prison. On May 17, 1917, the two Blackwell brothers went to trial in Crestview for First Degree Murder of Nancy Davis. During the proceedings, Will escaped, causing the court to declare a mistrial. Will was captured about three weeks later.

On July 2, the brothers stood trial for the murder of Bud Davis. Both were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.

Then the Florida Supreme Court reversed the judgment in 1918 on grounds of judicial prejudice and condemned improper arguments to the jury. A new trial was ordered. This time, though, the defense attorneys argued that the Blackwells couldn’t receive a fair trial in Okaloosa County. The new case was held in Bay County and the two men were again sentenced to death by hanging.

Will would never hang. He died of tuberculosis in prison in January 1919 while awaiting his execution. That left Robert to face the gallows by himself. On July 23, 1920, a massive crowd gathered outside the courthouse in Crestview. A wooden gallows had been constructed on the east end of the courthouse grounds.

The event drew a massive, noisy crowd that gathered around the courthouse lawn in a festive, fair-like environment. Local children were dismissed from school to attend, and vendors sold items like boiled peanuts and ice water.

Before the execution, Robert Blackwell was given the opportunity to speak to the massive crowd, gathered to see him executed. He took his time and spoke to the large crowd for roughly 20 minutes from the scaffold before the noose was fashioned to his neck and the black hood was pulled over his face. His hanging marked the first legal execution and public hanging in Okaloosa County’s history.

Today, the tragedy remains an anchor in Okaloosa County folklore and regional history. The Davis family cemetery, nestled in the landscape they once watched over, preserves tributes to the couple. Uncle Bud’s stone honors a patriot’s rest, while Nancy’s memorial marks the date of their passing—March 21, 1917—remembering her as an affectionate mother, wife, and friend to all.

Michael Earl Simmons


Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Sweet Tea Murders

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading