“Mike Simmons is a master storyteller and brings Pensacola’s true crime history to Life!” – Kate Hansen
“Amazing Stories. It’s interesting to hear the stories and know these events actually took place here. Michael Earl is a remarkable storyteller; he makes it feel as though you are present as the actual events are taking place. Absolutely one of the best events around.” – Mary Ann Mark
What did you enjoy most? “Learning the details of the investigation and how they uncovered the information. I like how the storyteller started with Ms. Buenoano being executed and worked back as to how she got there. I loved the local details.”
What surprised you? “I had no idea what to expect, but the story was really interesting and was done so well.”
Would you recommend Sweet Tea Murders LIVE to a friend? “Absolutely. Very enjoyable evening.” – Lori Menger
“Fantastic slice of Pensacola history.” – Mike Kilmer
“Had the best time tonight with Sweet Tea Murders, and yes the sweet tea was refreshing:) Best setting possible in the old jail, now Pensacola Museum of Art; very well organized, and Mike Simmons is an excellent story teller. If you’re interested in Pensacola crime history you’ll enjoy it for sure.” – Cindy Sclease
“Mike is a truly gifted storyteller. He knows the cases and pays attention to detail. His style is one that keeps you focused in on what happens next! I highly recommend his sessions to everyone!!” – James Donohoe
“Written stories are very well done and researched. The presentations are factual and well presented in a comfortable setting. The cases presented, for the most part, are so buried in history that most people would never know of them except through Sweet Tea Murders.” – Dennis Waldron
“My wife and I attended the May 28 storytelling event for Sweet Tea Murders, and from the moment Mike Simmons began speaking, we were instantly taken back in time.
Mike has a rare gift for bringing history to life. He pulled back the curtain on a side of Pensacola’s past that was wild, gritty, fascinating, and at times almost reminiscent of the Old West. You could tell this was not just a dry history lesson — it was storytelling with atmosphere, character, mystery, and just the right amount of Southern edge.
The stories were captivating, the setting felt authentic, and Mike’s knowledge of Pensacola history made the entire experience feel personal and unforgettable. We walked away entertained, informed, and wanting to know more.
If you enjoy true stories, local history, unsolved mysteries, old Southern scandals, or just a well-told tale, Sweet Tea Murders is absolutely worth your time. This is the kind of experience that reminds you history was lived by real people — and sometimes, it was wilder than fiction.
Highly recommend. We will definitely be telling others about it.” – Larry R.
