Looking for a unique way to spend a Saturday afternoon? Escape the Florida summer heat and step into one of Pensacola’s most fascinating true crime stories with Michael Earl Simmons at Bodacious Restaurant, located at 407 S. Palafox Street.
A Murder Mystery Rooted in Pensacola History
This isn’t your typical event. Guests will enjoy light accompaniments with Bodacious Olive oils and vinegars served with fresh bread while hearing the story of a real murder that took place in 1882 at the doorway of Hamilton’s Saloon, which once stood on the very spot occupied by today’s Bodacious Restaurant. As Michael Earl Simmons recounts the shocking events, attendees will be sitting at the exact location where history unfolded more than 140 years ago.
The Villar/Glennon Killing
The story begins with Captain Martin Villar, a respected Pensacola mariner who became involved in a violent altercation at the infamous Half-Way House near the waterfront. Villar was stabbed and later died from his injuries. His attacker, Glennon, was charged with murder.
The case seemed open and shut. But when Glennon went to trial, the jury returned a stunning verdict: Not Guilty.
That should have ended the story, but it didn’t.
Just days later, Glennon encountered Captain Victor Lyle, a witness who had testified against him, at Hamilton’s Saloon. Another confrontation erupted. This time, Glennon would not walk away.
Join us as we explore a tale of violence, controversy, justice, revenge, and the people who shaped Pensacola’s past.
Meet the Presenter
Michael Earl Simmons is a retired Pensacola Police Department sergeant, former homicide investigator, police historian, author, and creator of Sweet Tea Murders.
Drawing on more than three decades of law enforcement experience and a lifelong passion for local history, Simmons brings forgotten Pensacola crimes back to life through meticulous research, investigative expertise, and captivating Southern storytelling.
What’s Included
- A fascinating presentation of local history by Michael Earl Simmons
- Light accompaniments featuring Bodacious olive oils and vinegars served with fresh bread
- Sweet tea service throughout the event
Join Us
When? Saturday, August 22, 2026, 2:30-4:30 pm
Where? Bodacious Restaurant, 407 S. Palafox Street in downtown Pensacola
Whether you’re a history buff, true crime enthusiast, or simply looking for a memorable afternoon downtown, Midday Murder Mystery offers a one-of-a-kind experience.
Take a break from the Palafox Market, enjoy a relaxing lunch, sip sweet tea, and discover the story behind a murder that happened right where you’re sitting.
Get Tickets
Reserve your spot today through Eventbrite:
👉 Purchase Midday Murder Mystery Tickets
Seats are limited, so early registration is encouraged.